Get my free email updates!

Most Irresistible Pies in New Jersey

Whether you're craving a tried and true classic or want to take a bite of something uniquely satisfying this list of irresistible pies in New Jersey will serve even the most seasoned pie aficionados.

Emery's Berry Farm Blueberry Pie

As the fall and winter seasons quickly approach there is perhaps no better time than now to dig into a delicious sweet pie. Classic apple or blueberry pies are in abundance in New Jersey this time of year but also a variety of uniquely special ones from talented bakers and dessert shops. Whether you are looking for a tried and true classic or want to take a bite of something completely new this list of irresistible pies in New Jersey will satisfy even the most seasoned pie aficionados. Dig in and enjoy!

Mr. Tod’s Pie Factory (Englewood, NJ)

Mr. Tods Pie Shop, Englewood New Jersey, Chocolate Pecan Pie - Pies in New Jersey
Chocolate Pecan Pie | via Mr. Todd’s Pie Factory Facebook

Location: 15 W Hudson Ave, Englewood, New Jersey

As a native New Yorker raised in the Cavalier Manor section of Portsmouth, Virginia, Mr. Tod has had his eyes on the pies for quite some time. In 2002, Mr. Tod’s Pie Factory was founded in Somerset, New Jersey. In 2009, Mr. Tod became the 1st entrepreneur on ABC’s hit show, Shark Tank, and his pies landed on the national stage. Shortly thereafter he began to ship his pies nationwide.

Country Living Magazine and Oprah have named Mr. Tod’s one of the best mail order pie companies in America. Mr. Tod’s has also been featured in the New York Times, on The Today Show, The Food Network, CNBC and more.

Mr. Tod’s Website – https://mrtods.com/about/

Pies in New Jersey at Mr. Tod’s Pie Factory to try:

  • Chocolate Pecan Pie
  • Buttermilk Coconut Pie
  • Lemon Chess Pie
Read Delk M.‘s review of Mr. Tod’s Pie Factory on Yelp

Emery’s Berry Farm (New Egypt, NJ)

Blueberry Pie from Emory's Berry Farm in New Egypt, New Jersey
Blueberry Pie | via ralph612 Instagram

Location: 346 Long Swamp Road, New Egypt, NJ 08533

Emery’s has grown and sold berries and farm fresh baked goods to New Jerseyans 50 years. Their pies are baked and sold seven days a week alongside a variety of jellies, preserves, and spreads. Sunflowers are grown and cut on the farm – bunched up at the farm market all of July, August & September. They also offer hayrides and corn mazes. 

Emery’s Berry Farm Website – http://www.emerysfarm.com/

Pies in New Jersey at Emery’s Berry Farm to try:

  • Trifecta Pie – Blueberry, peaches, cherries all in one pie
  • Blueberry Pie 
  • Apple Crumb Pie
Read Kristina D.‘s review of Emery’s Organic Blueberry Farm on Yelp

Penza’s Pies at the Red Barn (Hammonton, NJ)

Pies at Penza's Pies at the Red Barn in Hammonton, New Jersey - Pies in New Jersey
Pie Assortment | via Penza’s Pies at the Red Barn Cafe Facebook

Location:  51 S Myrtle St, Hammonton, NJ 08037

Nestled in the heart of New Jersey’s Pinelands is a 120 year old red barn that once housed a multitude of farm stock, and later served as a packing house for tomatoes, peaches, apples and an assortment of other Jersey produce now silently stands and welcomes the traveler.

The Red Barn has grown from what was once a small farm market, to a bustling cafe, bakery, farm market, and greenhouse.

Penza’s Pies at the Red Barn Website – http://www.penzaspies.com/history.php

Pies in New Jersey at Penza’s Pies to try:

  • Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
  • Blueberry Pie
  • Cherry Pie
Read Danielle L.‘s review of Penza’s Pies at the Red Barn Cafe on Yelp

The Pie Store (Upper Montclair, NJ)

Strawberry-Rhubarb Small Pie from The Pie Store, photo by Florence C. Yelp
Strawberry-Rhubarb Small Pie / via Florence C. Yelp

Location: 100 Watchung Avenue, Upper Montclair, NJ

Everything is made with 100% fresh ingredients on a daily basis. These are our regular pies, but we also have seasonal specials such as pumpkin in the fall and rhubarb in the late spring. We cannot guarantee that everything listed here will be in store, so make sure to call before your visit! 

The Pie Store Facebook – https://www.facebook.com/pg/The-Pie-Store-193409458920/about/

Pies in New Jersey at The Pie Store to try:

  • Banoffee Pie – dessert pie made from bananas, cream and toffee, combined either on a buttery biscuit base
  • Key Lime Pie
  • Coconut Custard Pie
Read Greg T.‘s review of The Pie Store on Yelp

Erie Coffee & Bakery (Rutherford, NJ)

Peach Pie from Erie Coffee and Bakery
Peach Pie / via Erie Coffee & Bakery Facebook

Location10 Franklin Pl, Rutherford, NJ 07070

Erie is a Coffeeshop & Bakery in Rutherford, NJ, serves locally roasted coffee and hand crafted, small batch baked goods. 10 Franklin Place is the home of a sunny, fun, creative open kitchen that only uses the highest and best quality of everything. In our beautifully designed shop we conjure up all of our homemade sweet and savory seasonal treats as well a selection of roasts from Cafe Grumpy of Brooklyn, NY.

Erie Coffee and Bakery Website – http://www.eatdrinkerie.com/

Pies in New Jersey at Erie Coffee & Bakery to try:

  • Apple Caramel Pie
  • Peach Pie
  • Pumpkin & Bourbon Pecan Pie
Read Mary J.‘s review of Erie Coffee & Bakery on Yelp

Hainesville General Store (Branchville, NJ)

Apple Crumb Pie from Hainesville General Store in Branchville, New Jersey
Apple Crumb Pie | via Milo I. Yelp

Location: 283 US-206, Branchville, NJ 07826

Located in Beautiful Sussex County, NJ, only 1 mile from the Delaware River, this Landmark has been in continuous operation since 1883.
Come, Step Back in Time & Browse our antique filled store. Sample our Menu of Delicious Sandwiches, Homemade baked Goods and Our Own Soda! We are also a full Service Caterer with over 30 years experience.

Hainesville General Store Website – http://www.hainesvillegeneralstore.com/about-us.html

Pies in New Jersey at Hainesville General Store to try:

  • Apple Crumb Pie
  • Mixed Berry Pie
  • Cherry Pie
Read Milo I.‘s review of Hainesville General Store on Yelp

Wemrock Orchards (Freehold, NJ)

A selection of pies from Wemrock Orchards in Freehold, New Jersey
Pie Assortment | via Wemrock Orchards Facebook

Location: 100 Wemrock Rd, Freehold, NJ 07728

Wemrock Orchards, Inc. is a family owned and operated orchard in Freehold, New Jersey. We grow local fruits such as strawberries and pumpkins. 50 years ago, we moved our road side stand into the old packing house, which is now our Country Store. Ever since, we have been selling our hand-made pies, apple cider, apple cider donuts and fun local foods.

Wemrock Orchards Website – http://wemrockorchard.com/

Pies in New Jersey at Wemrock Orchards to try:

  • Traditional Apple Pie
  • Blueberry Pie
  • Apple Crisp Pie
Read Jonathan T.‘s review of Wemrock Orchards on Yelp

Donaldson Farms (Hackettstown, NJ)

Pumpkin and Pecan Pies from Donaldson Farms in Hackettstown, New Jersey
Pie Assortment | via Donaldson Farms Facebook

Location358 Allen Rd, Hackettstown, New Jersey

Our farm market and our shelves are stocked with a full line of fresh fruits, vegetables, fresh baked pies and other delicious baked goods, dairy products, syrups, local honey, our own jellies, jam, sauce and salsa, gluten free products, and a fantastic selection of local products from local vendors – neighbors and friends in our community.

Donaldson Farms Website – https://donaldsonfarms.net/

Pies in New Jersey at Donaldson Farms to try: 

  • Blueberry Pie
  • Very Berry Pie
  • Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Read Janet C.‘s review of Donaldson Farms on Yelp

Pie Lady Cafe (Moorestown, NJ)

Lemon Meringue Pie from the Pie Lady Cafe in Moorestown, New Jersey
Lemon Meringue Pie | via Linda S. Yelp

Location:  9 E Main St # 1, Moorestown, NJ 08057

Pie Lady Cafe is a dessert shop and bakery that serves breakfast, lunch, drinks and coffee.

Pies in New Jersey at Pie Lady Cafe to try:

  • Lemon Meringue Pie 
  • Blueberry Pie
  • Mixed Berry Pie
Read Pegah Y.‘s review of Pie Lady Cafe on Yelp

Pies & Quiches (Park Ridge, NJ)

Almond Joy Pie from Pies and Quiches in Park Ridge, New Jersey
Almond Joy Pie | via Pies & Quiches Facebook

Location133 Kinderkamack Rd, Park Ridge, NJ 07656

Pies & Quiches and small baked goods are what you will find at this new bake shop. All baked goods are made on the premises and from scratch.

Pies & Quiches Facebook – https://www.facebook.com/pg/piesquiches/about/

Pies in New Jersey at Pies & Quiches to try:

  • Almond Joy Pie – Coconut, chocolate, toasted almonds
  • Boston Cream Pie
  • Apple Crumb Pie
Read Lee S.‘s review of Pies & Quiches on Yelp

Know about an irresistible pie in New Jersey that I haven’t discovered yet? Please let me know including the pie and where I can find it in the comments so I can try and write about it!

If you are interested in more best in new jersey lists I recommend you read this list of the best gooey grilled cheese spots in New Jersey!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.